Flavor Rankings

Spoiler Alert!

This is where you can find our current favorite (and least favorite) sauces.

The sauce from the latest episode will be in bold.

Rank #		Sauce Name	Episode #	Season #	Average Score
1 –		MAX	0	0	10.0
2 –		IN-N-OUT Spread	72	2	10.0
3 –		Mike’s Hot Honey	69	2	10.0
4 –		Beaver  – Deli Horseradish Sauce	79	2	10.0
5 –		Bookbinders Cocktail Sauce	96	3	10.0
6 –		S&F Remoulade Sauce	96	3	10.0
7 –		The Olive Tap Chocolate Raspberry Liqueur Sauce	19	1	9.8
8 –		Pickapeppa Sauce	21	1	9.6
9 –		Chick-fil-A Sauce	33	1	9.3
10 –		Bertman’s Original Ball Park Mustard	14	1	9.2
11 –		Belizean Barbacoa Original	43	2	9.2
12 –		Sheetz – Jalapeno Ranch	68	2	9.0
13 –		KerryGold Irish Butter	72	2	9.0
14 –		“B●L” French Onion Sour Cream Dip	16	1	8.8
15 –		Lyle’s Dessert Golden Syrup	25	1	8.8
16 –		Duke’s Mayonnaise	37	1	8.8
17 –		Bissel’s Sweet Heat Maple Syrup	98	3	8.7
18 –		Sweet Baby Ray’s Secret Sauce	1	1	8.5
19 –		“CJ Foods” Korean BBQ Sauce	31	1	8.5
20 –		Kodiak Peanut Butter Syrup	76	2	8.3
21 –		Batch – Monkey Butter	78	2	8.3
22 –		Beaver  –  Cream Horseradish	79	2	8.3
23 –		Reddi Wip	88	2	8.3
24 –		Sweet Baby Ray’s Sweet Golden Mustard BBQ	8	1	8.2
25 –		Nando’s Peri-Peri Sauce	28	1	8.2
26 –		Soyaki Sauce	50	2	8.1
27 –		Desert Heat – Hot sauces	73	2	8.1
28 –		Coleman’s Hot Mustard	4	1	8.0
29 –		Ocean’s Spray – Whole Berry Cranberry Sauce	59	2	8.0
30 –		Daddies – Favorite Brown Sauce	27	1	7.9
31 –		Robert Rothschild Dirty Martini Dip and Spread	19	1	7.8
32 –		Papa John’s Spicy Garlic Sauce	45	2	7.8
33 –		Rico’s Queso Blanco	56	2	7.8
34 –		Heinz Ketchili	57	2	7.8
35 –		Bull-Dog – Tonkatsu Sauce	75	2	7.8
36 –		Stonewall Kitchen – Fig & Walnut Butter	80	2	7.8
37 –		Goya Medium Salsa Verde	85	2	7.8
38 –		Mr. Mustard Sweet Hot Mustard	4	1	7.7
39 –		Newman’s Own Marinara Pasta Sauce	18	1	7.7
40 –		Great Value Cheddar Cheese Wow	56	2	7.7
41 –		Jet Puffed Marshmallow Cream	87	2	7.7
42 –		Ferrero –  Nutella	91	2	7.7
43 –		Kikkoman – Plum Sauce	66	2	7.5
44 –		Open Pit Classic Recipe BBQ	2	1	7.3
45 –		Terry Ho’s Yum Yum Sauce	22	1	7.3
46 –		Redneck Riviera 1776 Original	39	1	7.3
47 –		Louisiana Lickers Sauce	49	2	7.3
48 –		Wholey’s – Good and Evil Hot Sauce	65	2	7.3
49 –		Sweet Baby Ray’s – Secret Sauce (Redo)	99	3	7.3
50 –		Yellow Bird Serrano Condiment	13	1	7.2
51 –		Belizean Barbacoa Hot	43	2	7.2
52 –		Papa John’s Special Garlic Sauce	45	2	7.2
53 –		Cava Green Harissa Sauce	52	2	7.2
54 –		Stonewall Kitchen – Gingerbread Butter	80	2	7.2
55 –		Mott’s Cherry Apple Sauce	94	3	7.2
56 –		Great Value French Fry Sauce	1	1	7.0
57 –		Unnamed Mild Herb Hot Sauce	28.5	1	7.0
58 –		Old El Paso Creamy Queso Sauce	56	2	7.0
59 –		Sir Kensington’s – Special Sauce	64	2	7.0
60 –		Carr Valley Pub Cheese	72	2	7.0
61 –		Tom Savini’s Vampire Repellent	97	3	7.0
62 –		Melinda’s Original Habanero – XXXTRA Hot	62	2	6.9
63 –		Durkee – Famous Sauce	60	2	6.8
64 –		Papa Palermo Honeycomb	95	3	6.8
65 –		Heinz 57 Sauce	7	1	6.7
66 –		Tobasco Chipotle	6	1	6.7
67 –		Yellow Bird Ghost Pepper Condiment	13	1	6.7
68 –		Texas Pete	39	1	6.6
69 –		Sir Kensington Spicy Ketchup	5	1	6.5
70 –		Rico’s Gourmet Nacho Cheese Sauce	30	1	6.5
71 –		Hank’s Grille BBQ	44	2	6.5
72 –		Burger King Zesty Sauce	11	1	6.3
73 –		Burmans Kansas City BBQ	2	1	6.3
74 –		Yellow Bird Jalapeno Condiment	12	1	6.3
75 –		Great Value – Traditional Italian Dressing	77	2	6.3
76 –		Amish country store – Peach Salsa	97	3	6.3
77 –		Corky’s Ribs & BBQ Original	23	1	6.2
78 –		Pillsbury Butter Cream Frosting	87	2	6.2
79 –		Winking Lizard BBQ Sauce	23	1	6.0
80 –		Frontera Especial Mango Habanero Salsa	30	1	6.0
81 –		Nestle Toll House – Pecan Turtle Delight Cookie	88	2	6.0
82 –		Koops’ Honey Mustard	51	2	5.8
83 –		Duplin – Christmas Wine Jelly	63	2	5.8
84 –		Mott’s Cinnamon Apple Sauce	94	3	5.8
85 –		Redneck Riviera 1776 Kickin’ Honey	39	1	5.7
86 –		Manwich – Original Sloppy Joe Sauce	82	2	5.7
87 –		Melinda’s Original Habanero – EXTRA Hot	62	2	5.6
88 –		Unnamed Sweet and Smokey Hot Sauce	28.5	1	5.5
89 –		Kari-Out Co. Chinese Mustard	47	2	5.5
90 –		Truff Black Truffle Oil	55	2	5.5
91 –		DelGrosso – Sloppy Joe Sauce	82	2	5.5
92 –		Olive Tap Black Garlic Balsamic Vinegar	55	2	5.4
93 –		Cholula Chipotle	6	1	5.3
94 –		Lillie’s Q Ivory Barbecue Sauce	15	1	5.3
95 –		Maille Old Style Mustard	24	1	5.3
96 –		Gravy Master	38	1	5.3
97 –		B•L Honey Mustard	51	2	5.3
98 –		Belizean Barbacoa Medium	43	2	5.2
99 –		Gold’s Horseradish and Beets	98	3	5.2
100 –		Mott’s Pear Apple Sauce	94	3	5.2
101 –		Isaly’s BBQ Sauce	93	3	5.2
102 –		The Twisted Ranch – Cheddar Popped Jalapeno	20	1	5.0
103 –		Barilla Rustic Basil Pesto	35	1	5.0
104 –		Alla Famiglia Vodka Sauce	54	2	5.0
105 –		Park Street Deli – Hummus Quartet	90	2	4.8
106 –		Yellow Bird Blue Agave Siracha	12	1	4.7
107 –		Beaver  –  Cranberry Mustard	79	2	4.7
108 –		Newman’s Own Original BBQ	2	1	4.6
109 –		Sweet Baby Ray’s – Sweet ‘n Spicy BBQ	67	2	4.6
110 –		Wahlburgers Wahl Sauce	36	1	4.5
111 –		Valentina Salsa Picante	70	2	4.5
112 –		World Harbors – Jamaican Jerk Sauce	81	2	4.5
113 –		Tangy Bang Sauce	46	2	4.4
114 –		Marmite	48	2	4.3
115 –		Campbell’s – Turkey Gravy	59	2	4.3
116 –		Kraft – Sweet & Spicy BBQ	67	2	4.3
117 –		Vienna Beef – Chicago Style Hot Dog Kit	89	2	4.3
118 –		Great Value – French Fry Sauce (Redo)	99	3	4.3
119 –		Hoff and Pepper – Lime Chipotle Dang Sauce	98	3	4.3
120 –		Wishbone Jalapeno Lime Vinegarette	32	1	4.0
121 –		Heinz Kranch	34	1	4.0
122 –		Deutsche Kuche – Bavarian Sweet Mustard	58	2	4.0
123 –		Three Mountain Yellow Sriracha	26	1	3.8
124 –		Heinz HP Sauce	29	1	3.8
125 –		Heinz Ketchup – No Salt Added	100	3	3.8
126 –		Ocean’s Halo No Soy Sauce	50	2	3.5
127 –		Chipotle Bitchin Sauce	53	2	2.8
128 –		Heinz Ketchup – No Sugar Added	100	3	2.8
129 –		Wild Style Garlic Parm	3	1	2.5
130 –		Hidden Valley Ranch BLASTED Dipping Sauce Ranch-Dipped Pizza	40	1	2.5
131 –		Yellow Bird Habanero Condiment	13	1	2.2
132 –		Patak Korma Curry Simmer Sauce	84	2	2.2
133 –		Sriracha Spicy Hot Ketchup	5	1	2.0
134 –		Doña María – Mole Sauce	70	2	2.0
135 –		Ortega Street Taco – Asada 3 Chile and Garlic Sauce	61	2	1.3
136 –		Hellmann’s Roasted Red Pepper Sauce	9	1	1.2
137 –		Bende Mild Paprika Paste	86	2	1.2
138 –		Hooters Wing Sauce (Medium)	10	1	1.0
139 –		Lee Kum Kee Satay Sauce	17	1	1.0
140 –		Bravado Spice Co. Ghost Pepper and Blueberry Hot Sauce	41	1	0.8
141 –		MIN	0	0	0